Poap approval request - #44180 - Highlanders POAP - Clan

  1. Drop ID 44180
  2. Community information
  3. Clan Network is a gaming blockchain on a mission to realize the full potential of Web3 gaming. Current Web3 solutions are centralized and siloed. They promise to grant gamers with true ownership over their in-game assets, but they fall short. In-game assets are still only usable and tradable in specific, siloed blockchains (i.e. Wax, Polygon, Solana). Clan Network is set to free these in-game assets from their captive chains, enabling multi chain compatibility, making these assets truly usable and liquide anywhere.

Clan aims to provide a superior development and gaming experience with unprecedented capabilities, by leveraging cutting-edge developments on the Cosmos ecosystem such as IBC, Starport, privacy through the Secret Network, and interchain security. In the spirit of Web3, Clan Network is a community-led project to the utmost degree. Clan’s core contributors, validators, and founding partners are some of the most experienced and capable development teams in Cosmos and crypto gaming
https://twitter.com/ClanNetw0rk

2. Nature of the event
in clan we believe that in order to build a game you need to be in one. this is why our entire system is built as a collecting badges that represent your lvl like in a RPG. each badge will represent a event someone achieve, this one Is the introduction ama with our CEO and we treat him like your “opening quest” in a game. this poap will be given to everyone that joined the AMA we will host and will be given with URL to their twitter profile by me in during the twitter space.
3. Distribution plan
2. during the twitter space with our AMA i will dm the members that will participate the minting URL.
4. Why do you believe this petition is being held?
i received 25 poaps out of 500 that I requested, I believe that I received only 25 due to a mistake thinking this is my first poap creation when I already created 2 with HeuRea#7844 via discord.
as for today I have 2500 members and 100 more then 300 that deserve the poap and are waiting, I am running super late in times its been more then a month and a half since my first request, I get that the past one was skinny and wasn’t accepted but this one was approved and i honestly have nothing to do with only 25 poaps… please try to help me.
Thanks

CryptOAV

Hey @CryptOAV

The POAP Curation Body made a negative review of your petition since it doesn’t quite comply with the POAP Quality Guidelines.

The copy (title, body text) and creative (artwork) don’t the significance of the occasion being commemorated.

Also, the distribution method selected is not appropriate for Twitter Spaces. For Spaces you should use Secret Word or Degen bot.

For future drops: please get in touch with the POAP Customer Support team before creating the POAP petition, so they can help you create your POAP drop :slight_smile:

All the best,
The POAP Curation Body

2 Likes

hey Fio i really do not understand what is happening, how come this one had a negative review and the other, who is exactly the same had a positive one?

you made a mistake thinking its my first poap and gave me 25 out of 500, this is after around 2month of waiting, i explained that i have nothing to do with 25 poaps as i need to give it to at least 300 ppl and even more and you told me to create a new request as i did.
i did it, get an answer after 5 days, that tops on the general waiting and its negative? i think you and harefue from discord knows exactly what is clan and whats the highlander poap meaning so i really do not understand whats the need to make me go through all of this when i am already 2 month late in my dead line due lack of answer from your end and yes, i admit, mistakes of mine.

but you told me to create a new one and youll approve a bigger quantity, i did, exact same event and poap, why is this one refused?

‫בתאריך יום ב׳, 16 במאי 2022 ב-13:58 מאת ‪Fio via POAP Issuers‬‏ <‪notifications@poap.discoursemail.com‬‏>:‬

Hey @CryptOAV

We’ve mentioned that you can request a top-up in case you run out of POAPs.
You didn’t request a top-up, you created a brand new drop. So the artwork would be duplicated, which is against POAP Quality Guidelines.

POAP is a Protocol for the preservation of memories. It’s still not clear who is eligible to receive this POAP and how you verify participation.

as i explained i cannot give only 25 to my members and then be like oh sorry let me get some more. ok, i understand, can ivget 250 and then as more WHEN i run out because i know i will.

as i explain to herfue and to you too if i remember correctly, the poap will be given to everyone attending to our AMA with the founder of clan network (and keytango btw).
we partnered up with several communities so this AMA will have a lot of participates, communities like $scrt, luna, atom, and more.

if i can get 250 so i can start giving them away and then ask for the rest that will be amazing.
if you could explain please how i ask for more because i understood from harfue i just need to make a new request that would help me a lot too.

Yoav

‫בתאריך יום ג׳, 17 במאי 2022 ב-17:39 מאת ‪Fio via POAP Issuers‬‏ <‪notifications@poap.discoursemail.com‬‏>:‬

hey Fio, sorry for spamming but i am stuck and waiting for your respond please.
if you need to me to request for an increase can you please guide me how to? i understood you want me to re-make a request and thats what i did.

Hey @CryptOAV

Is the AMA a past event now?
How did you track attendance?

–

For a top-up, go to the POAP admin panel and request a top-up from the button on the right corner. You will need the edit code (it was sent in the confirmation email).

Let us know if you have any questions or concerns.

All the best,
The POAP Curation Body

hello, based on a role we gave to listeners.
yes the AMA took place already and we plan on having the exact same for members that missed the first one due to time zone difference

thanks for your explanation, is it possible please to get at least the first 100-200 so i can start giving them away while waiting for the rest to follow?

yoav

‫בתאריך יום ב׳, 23 במאי 2022 ב-9:45 מאת ‪Fio via POAP Issuers‬‏ <‪notifications@poap.discoursemail.com‬‏>:‬

hey, sorry for the reping but im still waiting for a response…

‫בתאריך יום ג׳, 24 במאי 2022 ב-13:32 מאת ‪Yoav erez‬‏ <‪yoyoerez115@gmail.com‬‏>:‬

Hey @CryptOAV
I’m confused, sorry.

How did you give a Role on Discord to the people who participated in the Twitter Space?

A POAP is a digital collectible, minted in celebration of life’s remarkable moments. Each POAP is a gift from an issuer to collectors, in celebration of a shared moment in time. Here you can check the POAP Quality Guidelines.

Looking forward to hearing from you.

yes i am aware of what are the poaps, we gave the role by crossing between twitter profiles and discord profiles during the AMA, i hosted the AMA and had a list of all the participants, then gave them the role and now just waiting to get the poaps to give it to them.
long process but the only solution to know who is on twitter.
now i already know how to recognise my community twitter profiles so its easier for future events.

thanks a lot
if it possible to get those 200 poaps to give them away after a very long time and huge late it i will be amazing.

thanks a lot

yoav

‫בתאריך יום ב׳, 30 במאי 2022 ב-9:19 מאת ‪Fio via POAP Issuers‬‏ <‪notifications@poap.discoursemail.com‬‏>:‬

Fio?

בתאריך יום ב׳, 30 במאי 2022, 14:10, מאת Yoav erez ‏<yoyoerez115@gmail.com>:

Hey @CryptOAV

I’m sorry but we can’t make a positive review of this petition for the reasons I mentioned above.
You can request a top-up petition once you’ve distributed the POAPs, since Curators want to check the quality of your distribution.

Let us know if you have further questions.

All the best,
The POAP Curation Body

fio you didnt refuse to the request if you read our chat youll see that you approved it but only for 25 for the argument that this is my first POAP creation, which is not.

so
if the main argument of first poap creation (its hte third) isnt valid, why cant i get the requested amount like it happened every time in the past…?

yoav

‫בתאריך יום ו׳, 3 ביוני 2022 ב-10:37 מאת ‪Fio via POAP Issuers‬‏ <‪notifications@poap.discoursemail.com‬‏>:‬

hello fio, i am sorry for being annoying but i feel a bit unrespected here.
you said the reason i get 25 and not 200 is due to the fact its my first poapµ
i proved to you it is not so there is not reason for me to get 25 and not 200 if thats your argument.
i am in this poap creation process for over 2month now with no answer for the first 3weeks at all
i showed you that 25 poaps sadly are completely useless to me as i need to give to 200 participants and i find myself repinging you and begging for an answer.

if the reason for getting 25 and not 200 is first poap like you said and you can see in our thread, there is not reason for me to get 25 then.

thanks a lot, sorry for this message but please try to understand my position, i know you are very very busy but the past one never took so long ( and yes i am aware that it is also my fault for doing the petition wrongly in the first time).

thanks a lot

Yoav J Erez

‫בתאריך שבת, 4 ביוני 2022 ב-10:12 מאת ‪Yoav erez‬‏ <‪yoyoerez115@gmail.com‬‏>:‬

Hey @CryptOAV
Thanks for your patience.

I see you haven’t distributed the first 25 POAPs.
Please select the top 25 members of your community and once we see a responsible distribution, we can consider a new petition for more POAPs.

as i explained to you fio i cannot give only 25 because it will be useless, i had 200 listeners and i need to give it to them at once i do not want to give 25 and say oh sorry guys we gotta wait, it looks unprofessional.
please Fio i really do not understand what is happening here, every time you say something else and change your explanation for why you are not giving me the requested 200.
it was at first - first poap - false, its my third
now i need to use them first? - cant i want to do a distribution day.

please its been 2 month for 1 poap, the poap i did in the past took 2weeks and less.

may i please get my 200 so i can distribute it to their legible owners in a month and a half delay?

Yoav

‫בתאריך יום ה׳, 9 ביוני 2022 ב-15:52 מאת ‪Fio via POAP Issuers‬‏ <‪notifications@poap.discoursemail.com‬‏>:‬

hello fio, sorry for spamming you, i am still waiting for your answer please.

yoav

‫בתאריך יום ו׳, 10 ביוני 2022 ב-11:08 מאת ‪Yoav erez‬‏ <‪yoyoerez115@gmail.com‬‏>:‬

…?

‫בתאריך יום ב׳, 13 ביוני 2022 ב-11:59 מאת ‪Yoav erez‬‏ <‪yoyoerez115@gmail.com‬‏>:‬

Hello Fio, what is happening? Is that a way to handle things? This is just a disrespecti to me , the poap concept and yourself.

בתאריך יום ג׳, 14 ביוני 2022, 13:53, מאת Yoav erez ‏<yoyoerez115@gmail.com>: