Curator Guidelines: Creating Quality Drops

By: The POAP Foundation

January 1st, 2022

Conducting quality drops is an art and a science, which requires issuers to deeply understand the desires of their communities as well as the collector’s spirit. This brief guide reviews best practices surrounding creating high quality POAP drops.

Wen POAP?

POAPs are minted as an attestation to a collector’s attendance (physical, virtual, or spiritual) at an event; a gift from issuers to collectors which acknowledge the non-material (and yet, invaluable) contributions that members of a community contribute to its collective health. POAPs can be issued for special events and memorable moments of all sizes, physically or virtually, provided good cause to do a drop.

In addition, issuers may mint tests to explore platform functionality and claim mechanics, as long as tests are clearly marked as such (both in the description and in the artwork) and set as “Private” events to prevent cluttering various parts of the platform.

Creating a petition

Petitions for all POAP drops go through manual review by the Curation Body. This is a group within the POAP Foundation that bears the sole authority for determining which POAP drops are allowable, in order to ensure that the POAP ecosystem remains an enjoyable place for collectors.

The committee will automatically reject drops with any of the following characteristics:

  • Drops containing copyrighted content
  • Drops containing pornographic or sexually explicit content
  • Drops containing profanity or inflammatory content
  • Drops containing hateful or discriminatory content
  • Drops containing politically radicalized content, or those encouraging illegal activities
  • Drops that violate guidelines for copy and creative, as described below
  • Drops that lack a responsible distribution plan

Petitions should always be created using accurate contact information for the issuer, in case further communication about the drop needs to take place. If the petition is being composed on behalf of a large brand, the petition should be created by a brand account.

Petitions can be created via the POAP Issuer Portal, following the guide available here. Upon selecting “Create a Drop”, you will be presented with a graphic user interface to create the POAPs that will be dropped to your collectors.

Copy and creative

The public facing metadata of a POAP is frequently the aspect most appreciated by collectors, second only to the format of the drop itself. Both the copy (title, body text) and creative (artwork) should reflect the significance of the occasion being commemorated. Quality art and well-written copy are frequently the make or break factor for curators in determining whether a drop meets the standards for being part of the POAP ecosystem.

Apart from these general principles, copy and creative should follow certain specifications:

Copy

  • Copy should be written (or translated) into English, and be free of spelling and grammatical errors.
  • Copy should include some information about the reason behind the drop: What is being commemorated?
  • Information about where and when the event is taking place should be included.
  • Details on how the drop will be conducted should be written into the body text.

Creative

  • Art should be uploaded as a PNG file, or an APNG or GIF with a .png file extension.
  • Art should be cropped to a circular shape no larger than 500px in diameter.
  • For proper display across applications, file size should not exceed 200 KB.
  • Profane or explicit content is never acceptable in creative.
  • Copyrighted or trademarked content is only acceptable when associated with official corporate issuer accounts.

Distribution

Drop execution, or the format of the drop itself, is part of the artistry in creating great POAP experiences. The best drops - like gifts - recognize the energy collectors put into both nurturing their communities and into collecting POAPs. Good distribution aims to present POAPs to collectors with care, and makes a best-faith effort to ensure that one POAP is available to each legitimate collector. Collectors should not be able to acquire the POAP unless they met the eligibility criteria, and should not be able or incentivized to mint multiples by gaming various minting mechanics.

Some guidance to choosing a distribution method and sizing the drop can be found below.

Mint links

Mint links are individual links that entitle collectors to mint one POAP within a drop. These may be distributed manually, or in an automatized fashion per account on Twitter, Discord, or other platforms. Manual distribution is suitable for most small to medium-sized events, or properly staffed large events, online or IRL. Automatic distribution is a great option for online events, provided the system distributing the links is instrumented with proper anti-bot measures.

If you elect to use POAP Website, POAP Secrets, or POAP Delivery for distribution, the number of mint links requested should be minimal.

POAP Website

A POAP website generates a secret subdirectory under http://poap.website which allows event attendees to mint a POAP upon visiting for a short period in time. This is a great solution for small to mid-sized IRL events, due to the option of transforming the URL into a QR code for prominent display.

POAP Websites are highly discouraged for use in online events.

POAP Secrets

A POAP secret is a secret passphrase that can be entered by a collector into the POAP mobile app in order to mint a POAP directly to the collector’s wallet. This is a better solution for online (particularly audio-first) events with large audiences. Best practices for large distributions are to leave the minting window open for a relatively short timeframe.

POAP Delivery

POAP Deliveries are useful for any event which includes on-chain activity, whether it be past, present, or future. Given a complete list of Ethereum addresses, a POAP delivery can whitelist the set of addresses to mint a single POAP, making it by far the most reliable mechanism for POAP distribution.

Due to the snapshot nature of POAP Deliveries, the list of addresses cannot be updated by issuers after the petition is submitted, and test deliveries are typically not approved.

Sizing your drop

The number of POAPs requested should approximate attendance somewhat closely. Curators monitor the size and nature of the communities issuers request on behalf of to evaluate whether requests are reasonable. The choice of distribution method will impact the likelihood of particularly large drops being approved without revision or comment.

Petition review

After an issuer petitions the body to drop POAPs, the petition will undergo a manual review by the curators. Reviews have several possible outcomes:

  • Approval without comment: In the best case scenario, curators have no objections to the preparation or the execution of the drop. You will receive mint links (if requested) or notice that the POAP Website, Secret, or Delivery is approved to the email submitting the petition upon approval.

If you haven’t received an approval after 48 hours, we recommend reaching out to Curators via Discourse… You may be in one of the following situations:

  • Request for information: In some cases, additional information (often pertaining to distribution) is required by Curators to make a decision about the petition.
  • Conditional approval: In other cases, a drop may be approved with relatively minor changes to the POAP content. After revising your petition as requested, the drop will be approved promptly.

Finally, it’s worth acknowledging that not all petitions are approved for drops. The most common causes for rejected petitions are, in order of occurrance:

  1. Unremarkable” events: The POAP Foundation frowns on overly superficial forms of engagement farming. POAPs as a reward for promotional activities (like generic social media engagement, or simply joining a community) are usually negatively reviewed in absence of further information for consideration.
  2. Poor drop execution: Drops are rejected in cases where issuers clearly have no interest in, or ability to, distribute POAPs to collectors responsibly.
  3. Low production quality: POAPs are collector’s items, and as such, should be developed with a certain degree of craftsmanship. Low quality or repetitive artworks are often rejected by the foundation.

Ultimately, the final determination of whether a petition is approved rests with the POAP Curation Body, as the stewards of the POAP ecosystem. Professional communication and adherence with the guidelines above are both foundational to a respectful and collaborative relationship between an issuer organization and the curators.

Sequel: Curator Guidelines: So you got smoke signals from the POAP Curation Body

59 Likes
Is there a "trick" to getting POAPs approved?
Welcome to POAP's Discourse!
Looking to discuss POAP onboarding in regards to weekly occuring POAP
#19986 - HyperZen Happy Holidays 2021-2022 -- Additional codes
Thi is my poap approval request
#21640 For the early adopters of The Love Care Coin TLCC Wednesday, Jan 5
#22398 - ntent.art Og's - 2022 DROP 01/11/2022
#22530 - X-DAO Initial members 1/13/2022
#23738 - People DAO PIP1 Voter POAP - Linking to Snapshot plugin
#20365 I Voted - 1st_Election of Rivermen Council
#22335-Time Machine(Drop Date: 20-01-2022)
Event #22734 event is live need approval for additional 100 secret phrase codes
#22852 - Twitter fan poap
#22950 - TV-obsession.POAP request
#22852 - Twitter fan poap - No reply was received after more than 48 hours of creation
#23172 - Mosaic Antigen HIV Vaccine Safety Trial - InvExDis Video AMA - 2022
#23214 Study and Talk 5 years Jan16 2022
Codes not received
About the method to distribute POAPs at DCL for large events
#23401 - Orange Cat Club 800
#23557 - MMC - Fireside Chat w/ producer-director Mali Elfman
#23592 - Carbon Neutral go 2022 request(19-Jan-2022)
This is my third attempt to get extra codes for my POAP
#23189 - Early Supporter POAP
#22930 - 2022 WAGMI Jan 14
#23654, #23657, #23658, #23662, #23664, #23665, #23666 - Bancor Snapshot Proposals #01 POAP Collection
#24220 - Anomalous LTD Presets 'RGB'
No Codes Received - Event #22956
#23317 - NFT Networking & Shill! Episode 15
#23989 AEX Honorary Membership 2022 N0.1
#23838 - Additional codes not received
Poap codes still not received
We didn´t receive the Poap links
#24232 - Zodiac Elites NFT Pre-Sale POAP
#24767 - SwolDAO: Discord Community Call 5
Bear-Market Buidler #24956 1/27/22-3/31/22
#25235 - Introducing 'The Giveaway Artists'
Event #25719 - Haven’t received codes
#24439- BOXHEAD /&/ FRIENDS - DROP I (more poaps request)
#24232 - Zodiac Elites NFT Pre-Sale POAP
#25141 - Red Envelope 1 “Pots” - Drop Date: 01/22/2022
#23136 Happy Chinese New Year Tiger 2022
#25187 code request
#24614 - Happy Spring Festival - Tiger 2022 [DROP-REQUESTS]
[#25539] GenomaNFT.com 🚀 ‹Launch Week› [February 4th, 2022] #drop-requests
#25677 - Luna Puan | 1000 Puan | Ocak
#24479 LAPLAP POAP delivery
#25473 - AMG DAO First AMA 02/04/2022
Petition for Approval
#25469 - Fractional.art Lucky Trader Charity Water Campaign 2022 - 2022
#23877 - community call#1
#24174 Chinese New Year with Vitalik (02/05/2022)
#25348 - NFTAminaOG - 2022
#26250 - Rudimentary Poap Implementation for an NFT Team Event
#23243 - imKey Brand New Secret Box Pro
#27168 - Metadoge2D Robot Pet Launch Event
#27486 - I requested 5000 code but only received 100
Drop-request Event ID #28072 Launch LyonRock Group
POAP.delivery approval for event #26894
#27435 - Yanelis DAO Valentine's Day Party - 2022
#28699 - 百块富翁中的一块
EventID #26514 Delivery Approval Request
Requesting Approval for Event # 28657
#28445 - FF Ever Comic #001
Requesting More Codes Approval
Getting thousands of codes loaded on 28413
#27162 - nftfi Finance Series - Sotuland - 2022
[Needs Acceptance] Dino Babies x Kumo's World LoL Tourney
Rquest for approving event #28987
#1485 - KlimaDAO Infinity Launch
Drop approval how is it going?
#29602 - Cyber Cosmos World #1 POAP
#29604 - Brandverse X Jpunk - POAP 5 - WEBSITE DELIVERY METHOD
Reviewed by # 30350(today)
#1516 - Be My Valentine, please approve my POAP Delivery ❤️
Hi it’s been 24 hours and my poap hasn’t been approved
#29226 - haven't received a confirmation
No links & been 72 hours
Community updates and brainstorming process
#29226 - haven't received a confirmation
Requesting permission to drop our request
Navigating Discourse
About the Appeals category
Drop #30241 QR Links Not Received
#29896 - Celebrating Women in Web3 and NFTs
#33637 - Carl’s (virtual influencer) First Day on the Internet
29074 #29074 Name of the POAP: Order UP! ep #3 - Share and Pair
#30551 [02.28.2022] (The Morning Squeeze 50)
#28022 - Sugar Club & GraffitiKings Party DCL - 2022
#[30126] [03/04/22] [POAP.delivery]
#30913 - 8immortals Fam Certification drop-requests (Petition review)
POAP links not being sent :( Event #30704
#30859 - BOXHEAD /&/ FRIENDS - DROP II - 2022 (Need to change artwork)
BLOCKS 29610 Feb 21 2022
#30913 - 8immortals Fam Certification drop-requests (Petition review)
#31289 - Wednesday Workshop #3
#30583 - Appeal
Please enable our POAP Delivery: #1562 - Huddle01 – The Calm before the Storm
Requested Information for the Event #31572
Stop punishing the issuers
OMMG POAP no confirmation yet
#31319 - Trading Tokenomics Test POAP
#31585 - Past 24 hours, Claim Links haven't arrived
#33740 Only received half of the POAP claim links
Drop ID #31002 - NFT101-VeeDao Launch Approval
【drop-request】#31062 - Active Community Members
#36922 Xart Community POAP Approval
#33902 - IndexCoop - DACH - Twitter Space March 19
#34221 Request POAP for event - SugarClub Metaverse fashion week 2022
POAP LINKS not received #38757
#34293 Request for POAP
My POAP hasn’t been delivered yet for two weaks #33319
URGENT : POAP as a part of pitching
#37005 - EGSCard - DIAMOND MEMBER - 2022 : DROP - 4/4/2022
Ape Squad #36882
Poap not being confirmed
#37208 Request for POAP
#37923 Looking for an update on my submission b
HELP Why has not been confirmed what would I do to issue POAP
Requesting more POAP codes for event 26729
#39455 Increment Beta v1 POAP - April 18th 2022
#37120 requesting approval
#40751 requesting approval
#40512 request approval
Poap Codes Missing after 3 days
Never got the mint link
#40844 POAP Approval
Clan network 38925 second request
Application POAP, three days has not passed
#41711 #41710 #41713 need an approval for my Drops-Request
#42437 - Papes OGs <> 05/03/2022
MegaCube 2 DCL Event
#42194 Drop Approval Request
Freedom Squares POAP drop appeal
REQUESTED EXTRA LINKS AS ISSUES WITH QR DISPENSER not working
#43404 it's been over 24 hours. Please let me know status. Thank you
Awaiting Approval - BAYZ Event
Https://app.poap.xyz/admin/events/isro-into-metaverse-namaste-nft-bengaluru-2022-2022
Awaiting Approval on #44460
About the Issuer Appeals & Curation Policy category
About the Community category
Flowcarbon's Bounty Season 1 #56019
Drop ID: #57268 | Poap for Flamingle’s First Twitter Space
#52440 July 4 - Approval Request Unchained Crypto Insights Podcast 25th Episode
#51737 waiting POAP for NFT show Thailand
#57376 - Francis de Lara Treasure Hunt - Piece 2 - 2022
Drop #58731 rejected
#21691 - Year of the HPPR Request 1/10/21
#23615 - Happy Chinese New Year2022
Codes not received
#24116 AEX Community Program 2022 January 19,2022
How can the community help?
#22025 - nulink community event
#22050 - The Grow House Master Gardening 1/9
#45240 Need Secret Codes Only
#25141 - Red Envelope 1 “Pots” - Drop Date: 01/22/2022
#25473 amg dao ama
#25913 - lions of zathena twitter spaces
Event ID: #25684 Drop Date: 2.6.2022
Event Approval #25741
Event ID: #28748 | Drop Date 2/18/2022
The POAP website I created is not letting us Claim our POAPs
#26055 Image update and codes
#1317 Delivery approval
#27161 Chinese Community Lantern Festival Commemorative Activities
#26372 - PoC Early adopter - 2022
#25994 POAP Workshop by BanklessDAO (encountered farmers)
Discourse Request for POAPs for Event #27573
Event: #26429 Request
Haven't received POAP links
No confirmation email after 2 days #27820
DXdao - CPHFlames POAP #27792
#28304 codes arrived but due to picture we uploaded it's really tiny
.#28413- Daytona Raceweek 2022 w/ TigerQueen.io
#28873 - Sugar Club Metaverse & jackfrost_aLIΞN DJ - 2022
#28664 immediate issuance of 500 extra links please!
Not Met @erixink #28444 2/15/22-3/31/2022
Event #28074- POAP website Review Pending
#28508 - MovieShots - Let’s talk Film & NFTs #1 POAP Link Request
#1237 - G.I. Toadz POAP #4 Approval
POAP Website Approved but site not working
POAP #29338 - Cyber Cosmos World Warrior Badge
Submitted addresses for event 26610
#29710 - Event is live - need approval for secret word
#29943 MetaDoge Coin Race Game Beta Test Event (Drop Date: 04-03-2022 )
Drop approval for #28902
Positive Review on #22656 - Waiting on POAP Links
#32157 Secret Word & Links Not Received For A Few Days
25418 Yakuza Inc. Founders Special [January 31st, 2022] #drop-requests
#33637 - Carl’s First Day on the Internet - 2022
Please kindly approve events #33327
#29304 POAP Delivery still not accepted?
BTW DAO community's first ama event, request poap
30262 drop request
Awaiting approval #42594 - Values Extraction - 2022 -- second trial
Waiting for POAP approval 26h: #29586 soonperBLOX
#40007 - FOMO Party
# 31666-commemorating the closing ceremony of the Beijing 2022 Winter Olympic Games
30035 Queenz Collection
QR Links not received for Event #30261
POAP top up rejected (we need ~400 additional drops, ~500 mints in total)
## #30700 - Will Ville - Hearst Test 1 - 2022
POAP Still Not Approved After 4 Days
Art Exhibition POAPs
How Do We Know If We Got Denied?
#32114 - error when claiming event live
#31152 - created 2nd march, no approval, cant create delivery
#30700 - Will Ville - Hearst Test 1
Update on requested poap approval
Want to know the status of the POAP Drop
Approvel request - clan network 38925
[#29860] [0.2.28.22] [Mint links]
#33490 - Choy Madness Round 1 [Approval]
Michelle Trunzo - Event ID #22625 (In-Person Event) & Event ID #22656 (Virtual Supporter) - Drop Request
Https://app.poap.xyz/admin/events/isea-speaks-ep-2-2022
#36922 - Xart Community First POAP (03-Apr-2022 to 17-Apr-2022)
#34721 is still pending, please help
Did not receive links for Infinite Machine Art Review with Marlon Portales
Mint links not getting
Delivery Approval, Event ID 39049 Delivery 2053
Waiting for approval #37021 - FantaVerse Dragon Ball collection
@habitnest Joining the community!
POAP #36787 drop confirmation email not received yet
#37208 Request for POAP
#37398 - Attended Poolside with Polkastarter 01: Blockchain Gaming [Secret Word]
I have not received mint links
#38569 consult about this drop
#39214 - 4/15/22
#37722 - Paladin Community Call #8 - 2022 (20 more POAPs)
I requested 1000 mint links when I wanted to ask for 100
JRNY Club POAP Request
Review has been terminated? #39841
#39495, 4/17/2022 Drop Request
Appeal for Drop ID #35947 & #38114
Approvel request - #39373 #39374 #39375 #39376
#38652 Request more CODES - Multi Day-Drop on 27.04.22 to 30.04.22(Website Method)
Haven't received codes for #41659
Approval for new requests, why was old denied ? #39630
#40230 - Wagumi DAO 5000 people celebration POAP April 21 2022
#40803、#40804request approval
Event ID: #40591 - Art or DAI Battle #2 - Obscureprints
#41629 - 區塊勢終身訂閱會員(Lifetime Membership @Blocktrend.today)|2022 年補發
Still haven’t received codes ID 40944
POAP Approval - BAYZ Event (Few #)
#40803、#40804 request approval again
New POAP Drop created
Athena Protocol Mint Links Help Please
Still haven’t received the codes
Awaiting approval for #41798
Event ID#42230 Links not delivered
I havent heard back re my POAP in 48 hours, it said to contact you after 24
42996 - VolleyDAO x 2022 AVP Austin Open
#42112 Need 10 more mint links but can't request more codes
Delivery #2212 - Drop #42167 - Follow up
Cool Cookies Easter POAP #39557
POAP Delivery Approval - 39090
#43624 - Yellow community call #1
Poap approval request - #44180 - Highlanders POAP - Clan
Https://app.poap.xyz/admin/events/isro-into-metaverse-namaste-nft-bengaluru-2022-2022
#44256 9Fortunes Metaverse Annual Convention - Challenge Event
POAP #44211 drop confirmation email not received yet
IPN @ Cromuland
#43839 Add 50 Mint Links Please, !Urgent
Awaiting Approval on #44460
Requesting poap codes
Poap approval request - #44180 - Highlanders POAP - Clan
#44760 with a gif-coverted-png to replace an exisiting event
UMC meet (test)
Unable to issue POAP
Hi from PooZone (POAP Incident ID #51263, #51266, 51267 Request Approval)
Regalo rosa 2022
Request for permission #45203
Request for permission #45295
Event #[44438,21309,21310] Wilderness P2E game events
#45977 Final Champions 2022
Approval request for more codes
Request for POAP Event & Website Approval #51101
#45217-Awaiting Approval
Poap approval request - #44180 - Highlanders POAP - Clan
#47468 Awaiting Approval
#47463 Awaiting Approval (Gallery187 METArt Lesson)
Cryptotipsfriends #47500
#47107 add code
#47609 Urgent request for live event happening now
#46787 awaiting approval
Petition Approved for 50 Mints But Need 500 Mints
#47963 Awaiting approval
Drops - Event #48225
Delivery Approval 48082
#49920 — Futureswap Community Call #13
Awaiting Approval & Mint Links [#48585 ] [#48584]
POAPs did not getting linked
Flowcarbon's Bounty Season 1 #56019
Waiting for approval event #50462
Approval Status of #51035
Request for approval #51457
Poap approval request - #44180 - Highlanders POAP - Clan
I submitted a request for a POAP 7 days ago and no response
Poap approval request - #44180 - Highlanders POAP - Clan
Urgent!More code Request for #52089
Drop ID 50053 - waiting for Approval
#53299 Approval Request
[#54746 ] [07.14.22]
Did not recieve correct amount of mint links before event, now trying to switch to delievery method - 54143
Next.ID POAP "Delivery" Distribution (20th July)
POAPS and Titans: innovating education
#55848 Links has not received yet
Drop ID #58940 Waiting for Approval
Drop #58731 rejected

Hi there!

Sorry for bothering, but I got an email from Curator team regarding #22605 “NFT Networking & Shill! Ep.13 :orange_heart::four_leaf_clover::purple_heart:” and #22607 “NFT Networking & Shill! Ep.14 :orange_heart::four_leaf_clover::purple_heart:” to change the image for the unique one, but I can’t do it myself, so I was wondering if u would help me with it or delete our event so that I can re-create it again!

Also, u delivered only 20 codes for us when we requested 100, which is too less for our community, and we are not allowing a farming of them, we just reward the community members who attended our Podcast so that we can give them the whitelist spots once they collect needed amount of POAP’s from our spaces!

But I understand ur points mentioned in the email :pray:

Thank u for ur time and I hope we can fix it ASAP!

Much love and appreciate ur platform :orange_heart:

4 Likes

Thanks for the explanation of how to create quality drops! So many possibilities :slight_smile: Our team is excited to learn and give back to our fans with POAPs for memorable moments in time and being a part of the communities growth

2 Likes

Thanks. It’s really useful!

2 Likes

This was a great guide, thank you

1 Like

Hi i didn-t received approvation mail for my poap #29123 - Nft naming mascot yubiai

1 Like

Now I probably know the reason why my POAP might not be approved.
:sweat_smile:

I will do the relative adjustment for my request.
Thank you isabel!

3 Likes

Thank you :pray: i appreate the update!

1 Like

thank you for the info. As a new creator, its great to understand what works best. :clap:

3 Likes

Helpful, thanks! We appreciate the post.

2 Likes

Thank you. Very helpful. I’ve been looking for just this information.

1 Like

Help approving #39160

1 Like

Thank you , great clarification .

2 Likes

Dear isabel & POAP Curation Body,

I have one question about the petition.

We are thinking of dropping POAPs when the users of Over-the-Top media service have watched the movie contents.
(for example) If user X watched movie Y in Netflix, user X gain the POAP related to movie Y from Netflix.

Is it possible to regard “watching movie” as the collector’s attendance at an event, and use POAP like this way?
(Of course, in case all the copyrights are cleared)

Best regards,
Takuya Kojima (from Japan)

3 Likes

Thank you so much for these guidelines , very helpful and detailed .

1 Like

Thanks for the information

That’s really helpful,thanks for the guidelines!

2 Likes