About the Appeals category

This category is designed to contain petitions that seem to be “stuck” in the curatorial process, and is designed for public and transparent navigation of the petition review process.

Due to the need to have certain rules of the road followed, this category is restricted to New Issuers who have directed themselves through the onboarding process.

You should use this category if:

  • You’ve submitted a petition and can’t seem to get it reviewed within 24-48 hours.
  • You systematically have problems getting petitions processed.
  • You are genuinely eager to discover better ways of using the proof of attendance protocol.

Before posting, please read:
Curator Guidelines: Creating Quality Drops
POAP Community Code of Conduct

Please note that deviating from the Code of Conduct is met with little tolerance. Submissions that are appealed despite violating the Curator Guidelines are likely to be rejected, with a note that results in future appeals being given a lower priority going forward.

When submitting your appeal:

  • Please ensure your topic title conforms to the required formatting.
    Sample appeal: [#00000] [02.27.22] [Mint links]
  • Please conform to the provided template. Deviation from this is likely to create delays.
  • Err on the side of over-communicating. The more information you’re able to provide, the better.
  • Context about anyone you’ve been in communication with is helpful.

Thanks for your support in moving towards a better POAP Ecosystem Curation Process.

The POAP Curation Body

6 Likes

#33954 - Launch of NFT Artist- 50 links utilising secret word. Have not received confirmation email . Perhaps its because its the weekend . Am unsure . Thank you

This POAP is to celebrate the launch of Brenda Stone Art on Discord . The POAPS will be distributed to those community members who attend specific twitter spaces over a 3 day period and then join the Discord during those days . The POAP features original artwork by Brenda Stone Art and will be limited to 50 community members who join the Discord from the Twitter Spaces .

Saturday, Mar 19

#38981 4/17/21 POAP

(originally created 200 links, we thought we had run out based on the error response the first day, so I then ordered 400 more in anticipation of larger traffic, but only after the request noted that we had not sold nearly enough tickets to warrant having run out, and then on review noted that we had been limited to less than 200 drops, but figured you would see my request and we would follow up when I wasn’t shooting AMAs, then noticed that it has started minting again, but upon sending folks who had asked for it previously out to test, they were unable to get more, so I figured it was time to check in here)

“I asked for X POAPs, but got Y POAPs.”

This is probably my fault, and the result of poor design choices made at the last minute due to a change in plans from the Festival committee.

Originally, this had been a plan to reward voters with a POAPcorn.

Then there was concern that only ticketholders could vote, and even though we had planned a POAP for all Official participants, so that they did not have to purchase a ticket to watch the show, the committee still wanted to reward attendees who were there to suppor the artists during AMAs throughout the weekend who did not purchase a ticket, so we split POAPcorn to both an Attendee reward and a I Voted reward, and did the I Voted reward as a Drop request, and the Attendee reward via the original idea to mint it from the POAPcorn booth in the theater lobby.

With short turnover time, and not a lot of review we put this through hoping for some clemency due to the 1 time nature of the event and the limited location and runtime.

However, in retrospect, it is fairly clear that we should have used a Secret.

Is there a way for us to swap this over to a Secret method of distribution? I have seen several of these done, but not set one up myself before.

We have extended the run of the festival by a day, it will be running until 2pm EST on Monday afternoon, and there are at least 2 individuals who really, really wanted some POAPcorn to remember the Genesis Festival by.

If it is not possible to reload the links to the website, is it possible to obtain 2 links for those folks who have waited patiently while we discussed the petition here?

Thank you very much for running this program, I think POAP is a great onboarding tool, and respect whatever decision you come to.

Sincerely,

Petra~
@IxaBrjnko on twitter

Thank you for being so detailed. Appreciate that

Trying to find the status of a drop that was submitted online. The links usually come straight away, but it’s been 36 hours and I’ve heard nothing. Please advise :pray:

  1. Drop Information

BanklessDAO + MoonDAO AMA

  1. Community information

Twitter: http://twitter.com/banklessDAO

  1. Nature of the event

Ask Me Anything on Twitter Spaces with MoonDAO founders.

  1. Distribution plan

Using Degen bot from BanklessDAO for distribution.

  1. Why do you believe this petition is being held?

I understand this is probably the wrong place to be posting this, but I’m unable to post elsewhere, and your Discord doesn’t seem to have anyone actively monitoring for support. Thank you in advance for your assistance.

Hey @isabel,
maybe it’s me, but I was reading the quoted sentence a few times, has also submitted my appeal that was successfully reviewed, but only now I finally understood what “[Mint links]” means :see_no_evil: . I also have noticed, that other people just skipping this part in their appeals, most probably because they also don’t get it :grinning:

So, to make it more clear for everyone, I would propose to replace [Mint links] with [Amount of mint links requested] (if I understood it right :grinning:).
What do you think?