#33740 Only received half of the POAP claim links

  1. #33740
  2. Project WANA (we are not alone) is an NFT project aiming to lower barriers to mental health care.
    (https://twitter.com/kcdilla_eth)
  3. Nature of the event
    Commemorating the genesis launch of the project.
  4. Distribution plan
    I received 250 replies on my tweet and the first 100 will receive a dm with a claim link.
  5. Why do you believe this petition is being held?
    I’m not sure if there was a bug, but in my confirmation email it said I requested 100, then when I received the link it said I only received 50.

Hey @kcdilla

This is considered engagement farming :pensive:

The POAP Foundation frowns on overly superficial forms of engagement farming. POAPs as a reward for promotional activities (like generic social media engagement, or simply joining a community) are usually rejected in absence of further information for consideration.

Please check the POAP Quality Guidelines before submitting a petition for future drops: Curator Guidelines: Creating Quality Drops

I understand how it’s seen that way. It was intended to reward the people who attended the in-person event and my early supporters that couldn’t make it physically! It was a very genuine initiative and I’d like to fulfill my promise of distributing 100 if that’s possible. I’ll be sure to use a different approach for my next POAP. Thank you for considering.

I have an idea for my next POAP and wanted to check if this is allowed:

As I’m aiming to gamify mental wellness, I’d like to create challenges and reward people with a POAP. For example, please reply to this tweet with what you’re grateful for today. I will select my favorite 10 for a special Gratitude POAP. Later on these holders may receive utility for my NFT drops.

It can be a blurry line between genuine community building and engagement farming, so just wanted to check before I announce the initiative. Thank you!

Hey @kcdilla

if you set the eligibility criteria to determine a genuine participation, it should be ok :slight_smile: